Western-Challenged: Starting from Nothin’

Because I have a need to reignite my creative self, I saddled up with the Western106 folk. Then I promptly blew off the first week because work was busy, my feline companion is having health issues, and mainly because when asked to comment on what Westerns mean to me, I came up firing nothing but blanks.

As a kid, I never really enjoyed watching an actual Western. I remember feeling bored. And I don’t have any memories of a plot I understood. I didn’t care for guns, shooting, clouds of dust or men with menace on their faces. I didn’t find a reason to stay tuned.

Probably the first piece of media of the Western genre that I connected with emotionally was the one-minute PSA “The Crying Indian,” part of the Ad Council’s Keep America Beautiful campaign.

Given that this ad came out when I was around 3 years old, it’s probably the first “Western” I remember seeing. I think it probably colored my reaction to actual westerns and their often shallow portrayals of Native Americans (and women). I remember feeling like I couldn’t be seeing the whole story. And because of that, I couldn’t lose myself and just enjoy the story. I mistrusted the Western. Even more so after learning that even the hero I had connected with, “Iron Eyes Cody,” wasn’t a Native American at all, but rather a son of Sicilian immigrants with a wig and a lapse of integrity.

Growing up in Phoenix, my childhood relationship to the Western was even more muddled because of  locally iconic The Wallace and Ladmo Show. Instead of watching real Westerns, I watched Bill Thompson’s Nasty Brothers short films, where the Western genre was parodied and mashed up with other things like comic book heroes and Marx brothers-style slapstick:

These shorts, shot before I was born and aired regularly on local TV, formed my main impression of the Western genre. And that’s totally messed up.

The first Western I really enjoyed as a kid was a Space Western/Space Opera you may have heard of:

Star Wars

Over time I’ve come to understand the whole good guys wear the white hat/bad guys wear the black hat thing is prominent in Westerns. And that many many iconic film scenes are recreated from Western forbears. But I don’t know the origins of those images – where they came from first. I know I could research and find out, and that people will probably think I’m being lazy for not already knowing such stuff. It’s just never been a priority to me to find out.

A few years back my husband orchestrated an experience for me and a few of our friends who, for one reason or another, had mostly grown up without the pervasive influence of movies and television, and especially of science fiction. He had us watch a series of classic scifi films in chronological order of when they were released. We did this over a period of weeks.

Then, at the end we watched Mars Attacks!, and we laughed and guffawed our way through probably as many movie references as you can pack into a single film without your head exploding.

And I’m guessing I’m going to have that sort of an experience delving into Western106. I’m looking forward to it.


Don’t know who made this GIF, found it here.

So yeah, this post is a week late. That’s the way it had to be. Not going to fake where I’m starting from.

This entry was posted in #ds106, blog, media, meme. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Western-Challenged: Starting from Nothin’

  1. Hey, there is no apologizing in DS106/Western106 – -whatever you do is a positive, not a deficit. And I am stoked you are reigniting.

    I’d love to hear more about Wallace and Ladm0, it is totally a localized thing (in Baltimore, we had Professor Kool as a local kids show… I think). These kind of regional shows are a thing gone, now that we have everything everywhere internet-ized.

    The whole point of this is to put a marker down for your starting point of western reference, and see where you get to later.

    Ride on!

  2. cherylcolan says:

    Heh. This weren’t no apology, pardner. Like you said, just planting my stake.

    I can go on and on about Wallace and Ladmo, and I probably will at some point. For now, I’ll just share this clip of Steven Spielburg talking about growing up watching them: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HT3bGGKaS64&t=0m58s

  3. We are all on our own timelines – sometimes they just might be in sync with others. I agree – the biggest thing was you got back to it and WOW great post. Much better than doing your duty and checking off – you made it relevant for you AND for someone reading. Kudos.

    It will be fun to see where all the trails lead and how they track back.

  4. untertaker says:

    I know I could research and find out, and that people will probably think I’m being lazy for not already knowing such stuff. It’s just never been a priority to me to find out.
    This is a great project, finding out the roots of the western movie. You are the very first in western106 to come up with a project like this.
    Go on (and it need not especially to the West)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *